Lee County, FL
Pine Island
Pine Island — including Matlacha, Bokeelia, and St. James City — is Old Florida at its most authentic: a working waterfront and fishing community with no sand beaches (it's ringed by mangroves), the colorful artist village of Matlacha, and a distinctly slower pace.
The vibe
Pine Island trades resort polish for character — fishing, boating, art galleries in Matlacha, and waterfront cottages. It appeals to buyers who want authentic, quiet, water-oriented Florida living away from the crowds.
What's nearby
- Matlacha
- Bokeelia
- St. James City
- Pine Island Sound
What you'll find here
- Waterfront & canal homes
- Old-Florida cottages
- Stilt homes
Who it's for
Boaters, anglers, and buyers who want authentic, laid-back Old-Florida waterfront over resort living.
Frequently asked questions
- Does Pine Island have beaches?
- Pine Island is ringed by mangroves rather than sand beaches — its draw is the working waterfront, fishing, boating, and the Old-Florida character of Matlacha, Bokeelia, and St. James City rather than beachfront.
- How do you get to Pine Island?
- Pine Island Road leads west from Cape Coral through the small fishing village of Matlacha, crossing its bridge onto Pine Island. From there you can head north to Bokeelia or south to St. James City.
- Is Pine Island good for boating and fishing?
- It's one of the best spots in the area for both. Pine Island is surrounded by Pine Island Sound and Matlacha Pass, with access to the barrier islands by boat. Water depth and access vary a lot by property, so I check them for any waterfront home you're considering.
Thinking about Pine Island?
Talk to a full-time local Southwest Florida specialist — Logan Shea at Royal Shell Real Estate.